Birth Injuries Caused by Delayed Cesarean Sections: Is it Medical Malpractice?

Birth Injuries Caused by Delayed Cesarean Sections: Is it Medical Malpractice?

A timely cesarean section (c-section) can be critical in preventing birth injuries when complications arise during labor and delivery. When doctors fail to perform a c-section promptly, infants can suffer severe, sometimes lifelong, health consequences. In some cases, a delayed c-section may be considered medical malpractice if the delay resulted from negligence. Understanding when a delayed c-section constitutes malpractice can help families seek justice for their child’s injuries.

Understanding Delayed C-Sections

A c-section is a surgical procedure used to deliver a baby when vaginal delivery poses risks to the mother or infant. While many c-sections are planned, others become necessary when unexpected issues occur. A delayed c-section happens when medical providers fail to perform the procedure quickly despite clear signs of fetal distress or other complications.

Common reasons a C-section may be urgently needed include:

• Fetal distress: When the baby shows signs of oxygen deprivation, such as abnormal heart rate patterns.
• Umbilical cord complications: A prolapsed or compressed umbilical cord can cut off the baby’s oxygen supply.
• Placental abruption: When the placenta detaches from the uterus too soon, depriving the baby of oxygen and nutrients.
• Prolonged labor: When labor stalls or progresses too slowly, increasing the risk of harm to mother and baby.
• Maternal health conditions: High blood pressure, preeclampsia, or infections that could endanger the mother or baby.

When doctors fail to act quickly in these situations, serious birth injuries can occur. It is important to differentiate between a required c-section and an emergency c-section. While some situations require immediate intervention, others allow for more time for evaluation and decision-making.

Birth Injuries Resulting from a Delayed C-Section

If a necessary c-section is unreasonably delayed, infants may suffer injuries due to prolonged oxygen deprivation or physical trauma during the difficult delivery. Some of the most common birth injuries associated with the circumstances involving a delayed c-section include:

• Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE): A type of brain damage caused by insufficient oxygen supply, leading to developmental delays, cerebral palsy, or intellectual disabilities.
• Cerebral palsy: A neurological disorder that affects movement, muscle tone, and posture, often resulting from birth-related oxygen deprivation.
• Brachial plexus injuries: Damage to the network of nerves controlling the arms and hands, which may cause weakness or paralysis (e.g., Erb’s palsy). While brachial plexus injuries are most commonly associated with shoulder dystocia during vaginal delivery, it is important to consider whether the failure to perform a c-section resulted in a foreseeable shoulder dystocia and injury during the vaginal delivery.
• Skull fracture or brain bleeds: Excessive force during a difficult vaginal delivery can lead to head trauma and internal bleeding. These injuries are often related to the challenges of the delivery leading up to the c-section, not the delay of the procedure itself.
• Stillbirth or neonatal death: In severe cases, a delayed c-section can tragically result in loss of life.

While delayed c-sections can contribute to birth injuries, it is important to note that not all birth injuries result from medical negligence. Some occur despite timely medical intervention due to factors beyond a provider’s control, such as genetic conditions, maternal infections, or unavoidable complications. However, when an injury is preventable and caused by an unreasonable delay, it may be a case of medical malpractice.

When is Delayed C-Section Considered Medical Malpractice?

For a delayed c-section to qualify as medical malpractice, it must be proven that the delay was unreasonable and fell below the accepted standard of care. The following must be established:

1. A doctor-patient relationship existed: The healthcare provider had a duty to provide care during pregnancy and delivery.
2. A breach of the standard of care occurred: The doctor failed to recognize complications, did not act with reasonable promptness when complications arose, or did not act as a reasonably competent provider would in a similar situation. This means the delay in performing the c-section was unjustified and negligent.
3. The delay directly caused harm: The baby or mother suffered an injury due to the delayed procedure.
4. Damages resulted: The injury led to medical expenses, ongoing care needs, pain and suffering, or other losses.

Negligence may occur if a doctor ignores or fails to recognize signs of fetal distress, does not act quickly and appropriately when labor stalls or complications arise, delays the decision to perform a c-section without a valid medical reason (e.g., due to miscommunication or hospital policies), or lacks proper training and experience in handling emergency deliveries.

Preserving Evidence for a Medical Malpractice Claim

If you suspect medical negligence contributed to your child’s birth injury, gathering all relevant evidence is crucial. Key steps include:

• Requesting medical records: When requesting medical records in a birth injury case, it is important to include prenatal records, labor and delivery notes, and fetal monitoring strips. This process is typically handled by a medical malpractice lawyer, who will ensure that all necessary records are gathered. The lawyer’s involvement is crucial for obtaining comprehensive documentation to support the case, as he or she will have the expertise to navigate the legal and medical complexities involved.
• Documenting symptoms and treatments: Keep detailed notes on your child’s medical condition, symptoms, and treatments received.
• Speaking with witnesses: Nurses, medical staff, or family members who were present can provide valuable testimony.
• Consulting an experienced attorney: A medical malpractice lawyer can analyze records, obtain expert opinions, and determine if negligence occurred.

Seeking Legal Assistance

If your child suffered a birth injury due to a delayed c-section, you may have legal options. An experienced Indiana medical malpractice attorney can help by reviewing medical records for signs of negligence, consulting with medical experts to establish a breach of care, navigating the state’s medical malpractice review panel process, and advocating for you in settlement negotiations or litigation.

Birth injuries caused by delayed c-sections can have lifelong consequences for both the child and the family. If you have concerns about the medical care you received, do not hesitate to ask questions and seek legal guidance. Our team is here to help you understand your rights and pursue the justice you and your child deserve. Contact us today for a free consultation.

The Powless Law Firm is an Indiana law firm that represents victims and families state-wide in serious cases involving nursing home neglect, medical negligence, personal injury and wrongful death. If you have concerns about birth injuries, please contact us at (877) 769-5377. Together we can make a difference.